obsidian/🛡️ Debate/Arguments/Vegan/Argument against normal fin collapse.md

Argument for Fin Collapse Abnormality

P1) If a killer whale with a collapsed dorsal fin is healthy, then collapsed dorsal fins are normal.
(P→Q)
P2) Collapsed dorsal fins are not normal.
(¬Q)
C) Therefore, a killer whale with a collapsed dorsal fin is not healthy.
(∴¬P)

Proof Tree

Argument for P2

P1) If empirical data shows that most killer whales do not succumb to dorsal fin collapse, then collapsed dorsal fins are not normal.
(¬R→¬Q)
P2) Empirical data shows that most killer whales do not succumb to dorsal fin collapse.
(¬R)
C) Therefore, collapsed dorsal fins are not normal.
(∴¬Q)

Proof Tree

---

Hashtags

#debate #arguments #vegan #orca