mirror of
https://gitlab.com/upRootNutrition/obsidian.git
synced 2025-06-15 06:35:11 -05:00
1.7 KiB
Executable file
1.7 KiB
Executable file
Companions in Guilt
P1) If error theory is true then there are no categorical moral norms.
(P→¬Q)
P2) If there are no square-circle norms, then there are no categorical epistemic norms.
(¬Q→¬R)
P3) There are categorical epistemic norms.
(R)
C) Therefore, error theory is false and there are categorical moral norms.
(∴¬P∧Q)
(P→¬Q)
P2) If there are no square-circle norms, then there are no categorical epistemic norms.
(¬Q→¬R)
P3) There are categorical epistemic norms.
(R)
C) Therefore, error theory is false and there are categorical moral norms.
(∴¬P∧Q)
Companions in Guilt Interpretation
P1) If error theory is true then there are no square-circle norms.
(P→¬Q)
P2) If there are no square-circle norms, then there are no circle-square norms.
(¬Q→¬R)
P3) There are circle-square norms.
(R)
C) Therefore, error theory is false and there are square-circle norms.
(∴¬P∧Q)
(P→¬Q)
P2) If there are no square-circle norms, then there are no circle-square norms.
(¬Q→¬R)
P3) There are circle-square norms.
(R)
C) Therefore, error theory is false and there are square-circle norms.
(∴¬P∧Q)
| Moral Norm | Epistemic Norm | Judgement |
|---|---|---|
| categorical | categorical | gibberish |
| categorical | hypothetical | equivocation |
| hypothetical | categorical | equivocation |
| hypothetical | hypothetical | agree |
Hashtags
#moral_realism #philosophy