mirror of
https://gitlab.com/upRootNutrition/obsidian.git
synced 2025-06-15 06:35:11 -05:00
5.9 KiB
Executable file
5.9 KiB
Executable file
Strict Gametic Definition
Intended Usage
| Definiendum | Definiens |
|---|---|
| M | something (x) counts as male |
| F | something (x) counts as female |
| S | something (x) is a small gamete |
| L | something (x) is a large gamete |
| p | sperm |
| o | ova |
P1) Something counts as male if, and only if, something is a small gamete, and something counts as female if, and only if something is a large gamete.
(∀x(Mx↔Sx)∧∀x(Fx↔Lx))
P2) Sperm are small gametes, and ova are large gametes.
(Sp∧Lo)
C) Therefore, sperm count as male and ova count as female.
(∴Mp∧Fo)
(∀x(Mx↔Sx)∧∀x(Fx↔Lx))
P2) Sperm are small gametes, and ova are large gametes.
(Sp∧Lo)
C) Therefore, sperm count as male and ova count as female.
(∴Mp∧Fo)
Reductio
| Definiendum | Definiens |
|---|---|
| M | something (x) counts as male |
| F | something (x) counts as female |
| S | something (x) is a small gamete |
| L | something (x) is a large gamete |
| e | people |
P1) Something counts as male if, and only if, something is a small gamete, and something counts as female if, and only if something is a large gamete.
(∀x(Mx↔Sx)∧∀x(Fx↔Lx))
P2) People are neither small gametes nor large gametes.
(¬Se∧¬Le)
C) Therefore, people do not count as male or female.
(∴¬Me∧¬Fe)
(∀x(Mx↔Sx)∧∀x(Fx↔Lx))
P2) People are neither small gametes nor large gametes.
(¬Se∧¬Le)
C) Therefore, people do not count as male or female.
(∴¬Me∧¬Fe)
Gametic Entailed Definition
Intended Usage
| Definiendum | Definiens |
|---|---|
| M | something (x) counts as male |
| F | something (y) counts as female |
| S | something (x) produces small gametes |
| L | something (y) produces large gametes |
| t | a person with gametogenic testes |
| o | a person with gametogenic ovaries |
P1) Something counts as male if, and only if, something produces small gametes, and something counts as female if, and only if something produces large gametes.
(∀x(Mx↔Sx)∧∀x(Fx↔Lx))
P2) A person with gametogenic testes produces small gametes, and a person with gametogenic ovaries produces large gametes.
(St∧Lo)
C) Therefore, A person with gametogenic testes counts as male, and a person with gametogenic ovaries counts as female.
(∴Mt∧Fo)
(∀x(Mx↔Sx)∧∀x(Fx↔Lx))
P2) A person with gametogenic testes produces small gametes, and a person with gametogenic ovaries produces large gametes.
(St∧Lo)
C) Therefore, A person with gametogenic testes counts as male, and a person with gametogenic ovaries counts as female.
(∴Mt∧Fo)
Reductio
| Definiendum | Definiens |
|---|---|
| M | something (x) counts as male |
| F | something (y) counts as female |
| S | something (x) produces small gametes |
| L | something (y) produces large gametes |
| a | a person with azoospermia |
| w | a person with complete gonadal dysgenesis |
P1) Something counts as male if, and only if, something produces small gametes, and something counts as female if, and only if something produces large gametes.
(∀x(Mx↔Sx)∧∀x(Fx↔Lx))
P2) A person with azoospermia does not produce small gametes and a person with complete gonadal dysgenesis does not produce large gametes.
(¬Sa∧¬Lw)
C) Therefore, a person with azoospermia does not count as male, and a person with complete gonadal dysgenesis does not count as female.
(∴¬Ma∧¬Fw)
(∀x(Mx↔Sx)∧∀x(Fx↔Lx))
P2) A person with azoospermia does not produce small gametes and a person with complete gonadal dysgenesis does not produce large gametes.
(¬Sa∧¬Lw)
C) Therefore, a person with azoospermia does not count as male, and a person with complete gonadal dysgenesis does not count as female.
(∴¬Ma∧¬Fw)
Hashtags
#debate #arguments #transgender