mirror of
https://gitlab.com/upRootNutrition/obsidian.git
synced 2025-06-15 06:55:12 -05:00
7.7 KiB
Executable file
7.7 KiB
Executable file
Argument for Using the Term Retard
| Definiendum | Definiens |
|---|---|
| C | (x) slur's negative connotations have been neutralised |
| B | (x) slur has been rendered non-bigoted via altered usage |
| D | oppressed people will continue to suffer from the use of (x) slur |
| S | it is permissible to neutralise the term retard's negative connotations |
| A | it is generally permissible to use the term retard with an altered non-bigoted meaning |
| r | retard |
P1) For all slurs, (x) slur's negative connotations have been neutralised if and only if, (x) slur has been rendered non-bigoted via altered usage.
(∀x(Cx↔Bx))
P2) For all slurs, if it is not the case that (x) slur's negative connotations have been neutralised, then oppressed people will continue to suffer from the use of (x) slur.
(∀x(¬Cx→Dx))
P3) It is not the case that the term retard's negative connotations have been neutralised.
(¬Cr)
P4) If the term retard has not been rendered non-bigoted via altered usage and oppressed people will continue to suffer from the use of the term retard, then it is permissible to neutralise the term retard's negative connotations.
(¬Br∧Dr→Sr)
P5) If it is permissible to neutralise the term retard's negative connotations, then It is generally permissible to use the term retard with an altered non-bigoted meaning.
(Sr→Ar)
C) Therefore, it is generally permissible to use the term retard with an altered non-bigoted meaning.
(∴Ar)
(∀x(Cx↔Bx))
P2) For all slurs, if it is not the case that (x) slur's negative connotations have been neutralised, then oppressed people will continue to suffer from the use of (x) slur.
(∀x(¬Cx→Dx))
P3) It is not the case that the term retard's negative connotations have been neutralised.
(¬Cr)
P4) If the term retard has not been rendered non-bigoted via altered usage and oppressed people will continue to suffer from the use of the term retard, then it is permissible to neutralise the term retard's negative connotations.
(¬Br∧Dr→Sr)
P5) If it is permissible to neutralise the term retard's negative connotations, then It is generally permissible to use the term retard with an altered non-bigoted meaning.
(Sr→Ar)
C) Therefore, it is generally permissible to use the term retard with an altered non-bigoted meaning.
(∴Ar)
Argument for Using the Term Nigga
| Definiendum | Definiens |
|---|---|
| C | (x) slur's negative connotations have been neutralised |
| B | (x) slur has been rendered non-bigoted via altered usage |
| D | oppressed people will continue to suffer from the use of (x) slur |
| S | it is permissible to neutralise the term nigga's negative connotations |
| A | it is generally permissible to use the term nigga with an altered non-bigoted meaning |
| n | nigga |
P1) For all slurs, (x) slur's negative connotations have been neutralised if and only if, (x) slur has been rendered non-bigoted via altered usage.
(∀x(Cx↔Bx))
P2) For all slurs, If it is not the case that (x) slur's negative connotations have been neutralised, then oppressed people will continue to suffer from the use of (x) slur.
(∀x(¬Cx→Dx))
P3) It is not the case that the term nigga's negative connotations have been neutralised.
(¬Cn)
P4) If the term nigga has not been rendered non-bigoted via altered usage and oppressed people will continue to suffer from the use of the term nigga, then it is permissible to neutralise the term nigga's negative connotations.
(¬Bn∧Dn→Sn)
P5) If it is permissible to neutralise the term nigga's negative connotations, then It is generally permissible to use the term nigga with an altered non-bigoted meaning.
(Sn→An)
C) Therefore, it is generally permissible to use the term nigga with an altered non-bigoted meaning.
(∴An)
(∀x(Cx↔Bx))
P2) For all slurs, If it is not the case that (x) slur's negative connotations have been neutralised, then oppressed people will continue to suffer from the use of (x) slur.
(∀x(¬Cx→Dx))
P3) It is not the case that the term nigga's negative connotations have been neutralised.
(¬Cn)
P4) If the term nigga has not been rendered non-bigoted via altered usage and oppressed people will continue to suffer from the use of the term nigga, then it is permissible to neutralise the term nigga's negative connotations.
(¬Bn∧Dn→Sn)
P5) If it is permissible to neutralise the term nigga's negative connotations, then It is generally permissible to use the term nigga with an altered non-bigoted meaning.
(Sn→An)
C) Therefore, it is generally permissible to use the term nigga with an altered non-bigoted meaning.
(∴An)
Argument for Using the Term Bitch
| Definiendum | Definiens |
|---|---|
| C | (x) slur's negative connotations have been neutralised |
| B | (x) slur has been rendered non-bigoted via altered usage |
| D | oppressed people will continue to suffer from the use of (x) slur |
| S | it is permissible to neutralise (x) slur's negative connotations |
| A | it is generally permissible to use (x) slur with an altered non-bigoted meaning |
| b | bitch |
P1) For all slurs, (x) slur's negative connotations have been neutralised if and only if, (x) slur has been rendered non-bigoted via altered usage.
(∀x(Cx↔Bx))
P2) For all slurs, If it is not the case that (x) slur's negative connotations have been neutralised, then oppressed people will continue to suffer from the use of (x) slur.
(∀x(¬Cx→Dx))
P3) It is not the case that the term bitch's negative connotations have been neutralised.
(¬Cb)
P4) If the term bitch has not been rendered non-bigoted via altered usage and oppressed people will continue to suffer from the use of the term bitch, then it is permissible to neutralise the term bitch's negative connotations.
(¬Bb∧Db→Sb)
P5) If it is permissible to neutralise the term bitch's negative connotations, then It is generally permissible to use the term bitch with an altered non-bigoted meaning.
(Sb→Ab)
C) Therefore, it is generally permissible to use the term bitch with an altered non-bigoted meaning.
(∴Ab)
(∀x(Cx↔Bx))
P2) For all slurs, If it is not the case that (x) slur's negative connotations have been neutralised, then oppressed people will continue to suffer from the use of (x) slur.
(∀x(¬Cx→Dx))
P3) It is not the case that the term bitch's negative connotations have been neutralised.
(¬Cb)
P4) If the term bitch has not been rendered non-bigoted via altered usage and oppressed people will continue to suffer from the use of the term bitch, then it is permissible to neutralise the term bitch's negative connotations.
(¬Bb∧Db→Sb)
P5) If it is permissible to neutralise the term bitch's negative connotations, then It is generally permissible to use the term bitch with an altered non-bigoted meaning.
(Sb→Ab)
C) Therefore, it is generally permissible to use the term bitch with an altered non-bigoted meaning.
(∴Ab)
Hashtags
#debate #arguments #slur #retard #linguistic_prescriptivism