obsidian/🛡️ Debate/Opponents/Jake Mey.md

Debate 1

Proposition

"Vegan Fridays are harmful to children."

Arguments

Jake's Argument Against Vegan Fridays

P1) If Vegan Friday meals are unhealthy for children, then it is wrong to feed a Vegan Friday meals to children once per week.
(P→Q)
P2) If Vegan Friday meals are unhealthy for children.
(P)
C) Therefore, It is wrong to feed Vegan Friday meals to children once per week.
(∴Q)

Proof Tree

Analysis

Jake Consistency Checker

P1) If children undereat plant foods more than they undereat animal foods, then Meatless Mondays are more likely result in nutritional adequacy in children compared to a policy that increases animal foods.
(P→Q)
P2) Children undereat plant foods more than they undereat animal foods.
(P)
C) Therefore, Meatless Mondays are more likely result in nutritional adequacy in children compared to an intervention that increases animal foods.
(∴Q)

Proof Tree

1. To think Vegan Fridays meaningfully affect health negatively is hilarious
   1. Assuming around 38 school weeks per year and one vegan meal per week, that's just (38/(365x3))x100=3% of the diet.
   2. It's even lower when you consider that it's only a small proportion of the meal that is being replaced.
      1. Assuming it's only a quarter of the diet, it would be ((38/4)/(365x3))x100=0.86% of the total diet.

---

Hashtags

#debate #debate_opponents #clowns #clownery #plant_foods #animal_foods #public_health