mirror of
https://gitlab.com/upRootNutrition/obsidian.git
synced 2025-06-15 23:25:13 -05:00
2.7 KiB
2.7 KiB
Debate 1
Proposition
"veganism is immoral."
Argument
| Definiendum | Definiens |
|---|---|
| C | one has an obligation to convince others of something (x) |
| M | something (x) is a moral obligation |
| O | it is immoral to convince others of something (x) |
| I | something (x) is immoral |
| v | veganism |
P1) One has an obligation to convince others of something if and only if that something is a moral obligation.
∀x(Cx↔Mx)
P2) It is immoral to convince others of something if and only if that something is not a moral obligation.
∀x(Ox↔¬Mx
P3) Veganism is not a moral obligation.
(¬Mv)
P4) If it is immoral to convince others of veganism, then veganism is immoral.
()
C) Therefore, veganism is immoral.
(∴Iv)
∀x(Cx↔Mx)
P2) It is immoral to convince others of something if and only if that something is not a moral obligation.
∀x(Ox↔¬Mx
P3) Veganism is not a moral obligation.
(¬Mv)
P4) If it is immoral to convince others of veganism, then veganism is immoral.
()
C) Therefore, veganism is immoral.
(∴Iv)
Reductio
| Definiendum | Definiens |
|---|---|
| C | one has an obligation to convince others of something (x) |
| M | something (x) is a moral obligation |
| b | abstaining from baby rape |
P1) One has an obligation to convince others of something if and only if that something is a moral obligation..
(∀x(Cx↔Mx))
P2) Abstaining from baby rape is a moral obligation..
(Mb)
C) Therefore, one has an obligation to convince others to abstain from baby rape.
(∴Cb)
(∀x(Cx↔Mx))
P2) Abstaining from baby rape is a moral obligation..
(Mb)
C) Therefore, one has an obligation to convince others to abstain from baby rape.
(∴Cb)
Hashtags
#debate #debate_opponents #clowns #clownery