diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/AnnChilders.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/AnnChilders.elm
index 746dbfe..ff6295e 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/AnnChilders.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/AnnChilders.elm
@@ -16,9 +16,9 @@ cuckAnnChilders =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/The_Nutrivore/status/1447245484356108292?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = RanAway
-          , dodgeProposition = "diets humans thrived on in the wild, sans dentists and doctors, are correct."
+          , dodgeProposition = "Diets humans thrived on in the wild, sans dentists and doctors, are correct."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Agnostic
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = Vague
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = VagueProp
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/AnthonyGustin.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/AnthonyGustin.elm
index 831c4a5..5747c03 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/AnthonyGustin.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/AnthonyGustin.elm
@@ -16,9 +16,9 @@ cuckAnthonyGustin =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/The_Nutrivore/status/1482502242632552449?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = GhostedMe
-          , dodgeProposition = "seed oils are not a significant, independent risk factor for public health."
+          , dodgeProposition = commonProps.propSeedOils
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Belief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = Specific "the aggregate of the data suggests seed oils are beneficial for humans"
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSeedOilsReason
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/AshwaniGarg.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/AshwaniGarg.elm
index 43cbbe9..8ffebf6 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/AshwaniGarg.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/AshwaniGarg.elm
@@ -16,9 +16,9 @@ cuckAshwaniGarg =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/The_Nutrivore/status/1443328350982967303?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "representing the protein content of beans by dry weight is misleading."
+          , dodgeProposition = "Representing the protein content of beans by dry weight is misleading."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Belief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp "It's unclear why we should care about the protein content of a dry food item if that food item is inedible in its dry state"
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/BartKay.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/BartKay.elm
index aa1bbec..cf2dd5a 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/BartKay.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/BartKay.elm
@@ -16,9 +16,9 @@ cuckBartKay =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M7vTJ02xxrw"
           , dodgeDescription = RanAway
-          , dodgeProposition = "a 100% Carnivore diet is the appropriate and best health choice for all people."
+          , dodgeProposition = "A 100% Carnivore diet is the appropriate and best health choice for all people."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Agnostic
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = Vague
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = VagueProp
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/BenBikman.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/BenBikman.elm
index 3d58c9f..68db999 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/BenBikman.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/BenBikman.elm
@@ -16,9 +16,9 @@ cuckBenBikman =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/TheNutrivore/status/1587547250074746880?s=19"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "the diet-heart hypothesis is false."
+          , dodgeProposition = "The diet-heart hypothesis is false."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSaturatedFatReason
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/BennyMalone.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/BennyMalone.elm
index ce7747b..d51d25b 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/BennyMalone.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/BennyMalone.elm
@@ -16,9 +16,9 @@ cuckBennyMalone =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/The_Nutrivore/status/1530933999610171392?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = RanAway
-          , dodgeProposition = "eating oysters is compatible with veganism."
+          , dodgeProposition = "Eating oysters is compatible with veganism."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Belief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp "Bivalves are not likely to be sentient, and extending them the precautionary principle has hilarious entails."
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/BradCampbell.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/BradCampbell.elm
index 5920ff4..6fefa96 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/BradCampbell.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/BradCampbell.elm
@@ -16,9 +16,9 @@ cuckBradCampbell =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/The_Nutrivore/status/1530933999610171392?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "canola oil kills you slowly."
+          , dodgeProposition = "Canola oil kills you slowly."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSeedOilsReason
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/BradCohn.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/BradCohn.elm
index 1251d25..a7cf725 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/BradCohn.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/BradCohn.elm
@@ -16,9 +16,9 @@ cuckBradCohn =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/TheNutrivore/status/1687535030862831616"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "seed oils are not a significant, independent concern for public health."
+          , dodgeProposition = commonProps.propSeedOils
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Belief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSeedOilsReason
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/BradMarshall.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/BradMarshall.elm
index 70c3d0f..96b05d9 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/BradMarshall.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/BradMarshall.elm
@@ -16,9 +16,9 @@ cuckBradMarshall =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/fire_bottle"
           , dodgeDescription = InTooDeep
-          , dodgeProposition = "seed oils are not a significant, independent concern for public health."
+          , dodgeProposition = commonProps.propSeedOils
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Belief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSeedOilsReason
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/BrianKerley.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/BrianKerley.elm
index 96c76a9..7bf37db 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/BrianKerley.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/BrianKerley.elm
@@ -16,15 +16,15 @@ cuckBrianKerley =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/The_Nutrivore/status/1483889771134926849?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "seed oils are not a significant, independent risk factor for public health."
+          , dodgeProposition = commonProps.propSeedOils
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Belief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSeedOilsReason
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/TheNutrivore/status/1783200352646619227"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "seed oils are not a significant, independent risk factor for public health."
+          , dodgeProposition = commonProps.propSeedOils
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Belief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSeedOilsReason
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/CarnivoreAurelius.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/CarnivoreAurelius.elm
index c8eda8c..d21815a 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/CarnivoreAurelius.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/CarnivoreAurelius.elm
@@ -16,9 +16,9 @@ cuckCarnivoreAurelius =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/The_Nutrivore/status/1538272143061815299?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "vegans kill 100x more animals."
+          , dodgeProposition = "Vegans kill 100x more animals."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Agnostic
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propEmpiricalClaim
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/CateShanahan.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/CateShanahan.elm
index fa077e3..a1a8cbe 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/CateShanahan.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/CateShanahan.elm
@@ -16,57 +16,57 @@ cuckCateShanahan =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/The_Nutrivore/status/1266438463634632709?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "seed oils are pro-inflammatory."
+          , dodgeProposition = "Seed oils are pro-inflammatory."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSeedOilsReasonInflammation
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/The_Nutrivore/status/1479497980570857474?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "those who defend seed oils are just regurgitating the garbage that the AHA pumps out."
+          , dodgeProposition = "Those who defend seed oils are just regurgitating the garbage that the AHA pumps out."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp "I defend seed oils and I've never even read the AHA's material on the subject."
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/The_Nutrivore/status/1487215337116508162?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "seed oils are toxic."
+          , dodgeProposition = "Seed oils are toxic."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/drcateshanahan/status/1516904406805057537?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "current levels of seed oil consumption are the main driver of the obesity and chronic disease."
+          , dodgeProposition = "Current levels of seed oil consumption are the main driver of the obesity and chronic disease."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSeedOilsReason
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/The_Nutrivore/status/1537544882532716544?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
           , dodgeProposition = "Nick is just following the AHA marching orders."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp "I've never even read the AHA's recommendations on anything."
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/TheNutrivore/status/1778616438116483102"
           , dodgeDescription = RanAway
-          , dodgeProposition = "seed oils are not a significant, independent risk factor for public health."
+          , dodgeProposition = commonProps.propSeedOils
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Belief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSeedOilsReason
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/TheNutrivore/status/1779185488521310601"
           , dodgeDescription = OutrightNo
-          , dodgeProposition = "seed oils are not a significant, independent risk factor for public health."
+          , dodgeProposition = commonProps.propSeedOils
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Belief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSeedOilsReason
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/TheNutrivore/status/1778616438116483102"
           , dodgeDescription = KillScreen
-          , dodgeProposition = "seed oils are not a significant, independent risk factor for public health."
+          , dodgeProposition = commonProps.propSeedOils
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Belief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSeedOilsReason
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/TheNutrivore/status/1798766450255253987"
           , dodgeDescription = KillScreen
-          , dodgeProposition = "current levels of seed oil consumption are the main driver of heart disease."
+          , dodgeProposition = "Current levels of seed oil consumption are the main driver of heart disease."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSeedOilsReasonCVD
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/ChrisBoettcher.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/ChrisBoettcher.elm
index c69562c..ce2a3a5 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/ChrisBoettcher.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/ChrisBoettcher.elm
@@ -16,9 +16,9 @@ cuckChrisBoettcher =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/MeggGawat/status/1669691841682210822"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "seed oils are making you fat, depressed, and sick."
+          , dodgeProposition = "Seed oils are making you fat, depressed, and sick."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSeedOilsReason
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/ClaraAboel.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/ClaraAboel.elm
index 3402a0a..98fd2f2 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/ClaraAboel.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/ClaraAboel.elm
@@ -16,9 +16,9 @@ cuckClaraAboel =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/TheNutrivore/status/1727510906655969736"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "polyunsaturated fatty acids are known to initiate cancer."
+          , dodgeProposition = "Polyunsaturated fatty acids are known to initiate cancer."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSeedOilsReasonCancer
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/CliffHarvey.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/CliffHarvey.elm
index 6249f9a..6d85a5a 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/CliffHarvey.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/CliffHarvey.elm
@@ -16,15 +16,15 @@ cuckCliffHarvey =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/CarbAppropriate/status/1372281626206507010?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "saturated fat in the diet does not independently increase the risk of mortality."
+          , dodgeProposition = "Saturated fat in the diet does not independently increase the risk of mortality."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/The_Nutrivore/status/1500650543886204929?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "saturated fat in the diet does not independently increase the risk of mortality."
+          , dodgeProposition = "Saturated fat in the diet does not independently increase the risk of mortality."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSaturatedFatReason
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/DavidDiamond.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/DavidDiamond.elm
index b6fca3f..faed38e 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/DavidDiamond.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/DavidDiamond.elm
@@ -9,6 +9,10 @@ cuckDavidDiamond =
         name : String
         name =
             "David Diamond"
+
+        statinProp : String
+        statinProp =
+            "Statin therapy is not warranted for a person high LDL-C on a low-carb diet."
     in
     { cuckImage = formatCuckName name
     , cuckName = name
@@ -16,15 +20,15 @@ cuckDavidDiamond =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/LDLSkeptic/status/1583471298306375681?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = OutrightNo
-          , dodgeProposition = "statin therapy is not warranted for a person high LDL-C on a low-carb diet."
+          , dodgeProposition = statinProp
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propLDLCausality
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/LDLSkeptic/status/1583481964840902656?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = KillScreen
-          , dodgeProposition = "statin therapy is not warranted for a person high LDL-C on a low-carb diet."
+          , dodgeProposition = statinProp
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propLDLCausality
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/DavidGornoski.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/DavidGornoski.elm
index 7da0892..1cab4dc 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/DavidGornoski.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/DavidGornoski.elm
@@ -16,9 +16,9 @@ cuckDavidGornoski =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/TheNutrivore/status/1525474063044550657?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = OutrightNo
-          , dodgeProposition = "polyunsaturated fatty acids cause obesity."
+          , dodgeProposition = "Polyunsaturated fatty acids cause obesity."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSeedOilsReasonObesity
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/DianaRodgers.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/DianaRodgers.elm
index 315674b..f3c1f11 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/DianaRodgers.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/DianaRodgers.elm
@@ -16,9 +16,9 @@ cuckDianaRodgers =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/The_Nutrivore/status/1365857401786814465?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = InTooDeep
-          , dodgeProposition = "saturated fat doesn't increase the risk of coronary heart disease."
+          , dodgeProposition = "Saturated fat doesn't increase the risk of coronary heart disease."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSaturatedFatReason
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/EdwardGoeke.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/EdwardGoeke.elm
index a2bfc6f..0027253 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/EdwardGoeke.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/EdwardGoeke.elm
@@ -9,6 +9,9 @@ cuckEdwardGoeke =
         name : String
         name =
             "Edward Goeke"
+
+        propSeedOils =
+            "Seed oils are inflammatory."
     in
     { cuckImage = formatCuckName name
     , cuckName = name
@@ -16,15 +19,15 @@ cuckEdwardGoeke =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/TheNutrivore/status/1773421625150746784?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "seed oils are inflammatory."
+          , dodgeProposition = propSeedOils
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSeedOilsReasonInflammation
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/TheNutrivore/status/1774154640403423359?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "seed oils are inflammatory."
+          , dodgeProposition = propSeedOils
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSeedOilsReasonInflammation
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/ElieJarrouge.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/ElieJarrouge.elm
index 14dab61..6371cf4 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/ElieJarrouge.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/ElieJarrouge.elm
@@ -16,9 +16,9 @@ cuckElieJarrouge =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/TheNutrivore/status/1506845469980315648?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "sugar, refined carbs, and seed oils are poison."
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeProposition = "Sugar, refined carbs, and seed oils are poison."
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Agnostic
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = VagueProp
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/GaryBrecka.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/GaryBrecka.elm
index 0652789..00583dd 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/GaryBrecka.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/GaryBrecka.elm
@@ -16,9 +16,9 @@ cuckGaryBrecka =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/TheNutrivore/status/1726664526316372125"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "linoleic acid consumption causes atherosclerosis."
+          , dodgeProposition = "Linoleic acid consumption causes atherosclerosis."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSeedOilsReasonCVD
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/GaryFettke.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/GaryFettke.elm
index 63273d6..26e3769 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/GaryFettke.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/GaryFettke.elm
@@ -16,9 +16,9 @@ cuckGaryFettke =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/TheNutrivore/status/1460983496524980224"
           , dodgeDescription = GhostedMe
-          , dodgeProposition = "at current Western levels of intake, dietary linoleic acid is not a significant, independent concern for the development of chronic diseases."
+          , dodgeProposition = commonProps.propLinoleicAcid
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Belief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSeedOilsReason
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/GaryTaubes.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/GaryTaubes.elm
index e7b168b..7601e1c 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/GaryTaubes.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/GaryTaubes.elm
@@ -16,9 +16,9 @@ cuckGaryTaubes =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/garytaubes/status/1595180467552018432?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = OutrightNo
-          , dodgeProposition = "carbohydrates cause starvation."
+          , dodgeProposition = "Carbohydrates cause starvation."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Agnostic
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = VagueProp
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/GeorgeMartin.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/GeorgeMartin.elm
index a86cdc1..53d90f9 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/GeorgeMartin.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/GeorgeMartin.elm
@@ -18,7 +18,7 @@ cuckGeorgeMartin =
           , dodgeDescription = RanAway
           , dodgeProposition = "Nick has killed more animals in his life than a mature bear."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Agnostic
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propEmpiricalClaim
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/GuyAustin.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/GuyAustin.elm
index 9d65bf0..ba58950 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/GuyAustin.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/GuyAustin.elm
@@ -22,9 +22,9 @@ cuckGuyAustin =
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/GuyNAustin/status/1687530045101744128"
           , dodgeDescription = OutrightNo
-          , dodgeProposition = "."
+          , dodgeProposition = commonProps.propSeedOils
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Belief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSeedOilsReason
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/IvorCummins.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/IvorCummins.elm
index a5e7d4d..7328de8 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/IvorCummins.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/IvorCummins.elm
@@ -9,6 +9,9 @@ cuckIvorCummins =
         name : String
         name =
             "Ivor Cummins"
+
+        propLDL =
+            "LDL does not cause coronary heart disease."
     in
     { cuckImage = formatCuckName name
     , cuckName = name
@@ -16,15 +19,15 @@ cuckIvorCummins =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/The_Nutrivore/status/1268600451693494273?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "LDL does not cause coronary heart disease."
+          , dodgeProposition = propLDL
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propLDLCausality
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/FatEmperor/status/1636920650156724226?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = OutrightNo
-          , dodgeProposition = "LDL does not cause coronary heart disease."
+          , dodgeProposition = propLDL
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propLDLCausality
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/JakeMey.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/JakeMey.elm
index b683938..507f751 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/JakeMey.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/JakeMey.elm
@@ -9,6 +9,9 @@ cuckJakeMey =
         name : String
         name =
             "Jake Mey"
+
+        propReason =
+            "Vegan Fridays would only change childrens' diets by <1% annually, and, if anything, this is more likely a positive change than a negative one."
     in
     { cuckImage = formatCuckName name
     , cuckName = name
@@ -18,19 +21,19 @@ cuckJakeMey =
           , dodgeDescription = RanAway
           , dodgeProposition = "Vegan Friday meals are unhealthy for children."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp propReason
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/The_Nutrivore/status/1490060813138280450?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = OutrightNo
           , dodgeProposition = "Vegan Friday meals are unhealthy for children."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp propReason
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/The_Nutrivore/status/1495419256737091585?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = KillScreen
           , dodgeProposition = "Vegan Friday meals are unhealthy for children."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp propReason
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/JamesDiNicolantonio.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/JamesDiNicolantonio.elm
index 0a0dd6b..97bfb3f 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/JamesDiNicolantonio.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/JamesDiNicolantonio.elm
@@ -16,9 +16,9 @@ cuckJamesDiNicolantonio =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/The_Nutrivore/status/1460788569388171268?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "dietary linoleic acid is not a significant, independent concern for the development of chronic diseases."
+          , dodgeProposition = commonProps.propLinoleicAcid
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Belief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSeedOilsReason
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/JosephEverett.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/JosephEverett.elm
index f508352..a7e831d 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/JosephEverett.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/JosephEverett.elm
@@ -9,6 +9,10 @@ cuckJosephEverett =
         name : String
         name =
             "Joseph Everett"
+
+        propSeedOils : String
+        propSeedOils =
+            "Seed oils cause coronary heart disease and cancer."
     in
     { cuckImage = formatCuckName name
     , cuckName = name
@@ -16,15 +20,15 @@ cuckJosephEverett =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/The_Nutrivore/status/1535334822825971712?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "seed oils cause coronary heart disease and cancer."
+          , dodgeProposition = propSeedOils
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/TheNutrivore/status/1555138038740680704?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "seed oils cause coronary heart disease and cancer."
+          , dodgeProposition = propSeedOils
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSeedOilsReasonChronicDisease
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/JustinMares.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/JustinMares.elm
index 5845a9a..6572b92 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/JustinMares.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/JustinMares.elm
@@ -16,9 +16,9 @@ cuckJustinMares =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/The_Nutrivore/status/1329266554089869312?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = RanAway
-          , dodgeProposition = "vegetable oils drive inflammation and are causally linked to weight gain and diseases of inflammation."
+          , dodgeProposition = "Vegetable oils drive inflammation and are causally linked to weight gain and diseases of inflammation."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSeedOilsReasonChronicDisease
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/KaitMalthaner.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/KaitMalthaner.elm
index b9e9c70..9dcc038 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/KaitMalthaner.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/KaitMalthaner.elm
@@ -16,9 +16,9 @@ cuckKaitMalthaner =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/The_Nutrivore/status/1503258756687306753?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "omega-6 is pro-inflammatory."
+          , dodgeProposition = "Omega-6 is pro-inflammatory."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSeedOilsReasonInflammation
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/KemMinnick.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/KemMinnick.elm
index d5495c3..ae74348 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/KemMinnick.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/KemMinnick.elm
@@ -9,6 +9,14 @@ cuckKemMinnick =
         name : String
         name =
             "Kem Minnick"
+
+        prop : String
+        prop =
+            commonProps.propSeedOils
+
+        reason : String
+        reason =
+            commonPropReasons.propSeedOilsReason
     in
     { cuckImage = formatCuckName name
     , cuckName = name
@@ -16,15 +24,15 @@ cuckKemMinnick =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/kemminnick/status/1469336100300726273?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = GhostedMe
-          , dodgeProposition = "seed oils are not a significant, independent concern for the development of chronic diseases."
+          , dodgeProposition = prop
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Belief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp reason
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/The_Nutrivore/status/1476990862793986052?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = RanAway
-          , dodgeProposition = "seed oils are not a significant, independent concern for the development of chronic diseases."
+          , dodgeProposition = prop
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Belief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp reason
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/KenBerry.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/KenBerry.elm
index 16021f4..2a69d90 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/KenBerry.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/KenBerry.elm
@@ -9,6 +9,10 @@ cuckKenBerry =
         name : String
         name =
             "Ken Berry"
+
+        propAnimalFat : String
+        propAnimalFat =
+            "Replacing animal fats with vegetable oils is dangerous."
     in
     { cuckImage = formatCuckName name
     , cuckName = name
@@ -16,27 +20,27 @@ cuckKenBerry =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/The_Nutrivore/status/1366524889067368449?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "type 2 diabetes is chronic carbohydrate overdose."
+          , dodgeProposition = "Type 2 Diabetes is chronic carbohydrate overdose."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Agnostic
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = VagueProp
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/TheNutrivore/status/1539720236701589504?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "replacing animal fats with vegetable oils is dangerous."
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Belief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeProposition = propAnimalFat
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSeedOilsReason
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/TheNutrivore/status/1539721408372039680?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "replacing animal fats with vegetable oils is dangerous."
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Belief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeProposition = propAnimalFat
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSeedOilsReason
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/TheNutrivore/status/1813969807521300615"
           , dodgeDescription = InTooDeep
           , dodgeProposition = noProposition
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Nothing
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = Vague
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = VagueProp
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/KevinStock.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/KevinStock.elm
index 75b34e7..389d0a1 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/KevinStock.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/KevinStock.elm
@@ -22,9 +22,9 @@ cuckKevinStock =
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/The_Nutrivore/status/1534927799911317509?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = ""
+          , dodgeProposition = "Saturated fat does not cause cardiovascular disease."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSaturatedFatReason
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/KyleMamounis.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/KyleMamounis.elm
index 4f30171..2514edd 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/KyleMamounis.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/KyleMamounis.elm
@@ -16,9 +16,9 @@ cuckKyleMamounis =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/The_Nutrivore/status/1389259133044477953?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = RanAway
-          , dodgeProposition = "statins do not prevent cardiovascular events."
+          , dodgeProposition = "Statins do not prevent cardiovascular events."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propLDLCausality
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/MartyKendall.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/MartyKendall.elm
index 30bd72d..c804eea 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/MartyKendall.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/MartyKendall.elm
@@ -16,9 +16,9 @@ cuckMartyKendall =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://twitter.com/The_Nutrivore/status/1310548994804809729"
           , dodgeDescription = RanAway
-          , dodgeProposition = "to access your body fat, you need to deplete both glucose and fat from the blood first."
+          , dodgeProposition = "To access your body fat, you need to deplete both glucose and fat from the blood first."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp "The proposition suggests that before one can liberate their body fat, they must first experience a lethal physiological event."
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/MaxLugavere.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/MaxLugavere.elm
index 2ba24d9..a433fda 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/MaxLugavere.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/MaxLugavere.elm
@@ -9,6 +9,10 @@ cuckMaxLugavere =
         name : String
         name =
             "Max Lugavere"
+
+        prop : String
+        prop =
+            "seed oils consumption is associated with an increased risk of CVD and Alzheimer's disease."
     in
     { cuckImage = formatCuckName name
     , cuckName = name
@@ -16,21 +20,21 @@ cuckMaxLugavere =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/maxlugavere/status/1517683567249149953?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = RanAway
-          , dodgeProposition = "seed oils consumption is associated with an increased risk of CVD and Alzheimer's disease."
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Agnostic
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeProposition = prop
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSeedOilsReasonChronicDisease
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/The_Nutrivore/status/1518307089742848000?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "seed oils consumption is associated with an increased risk of CVD and Alzheimer's disease."
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Agnostic
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeProposition = prop
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSeedOilsReasonChronicDisease
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/maxlugavere/status/1518367365683064833?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = OutrightNo
-          , dodgeProposition = "seed oils consumption is associated with an increased risk of CVD and Alzheimer's disease."
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Agnostic
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeProposition = prop
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSeedOilsReasonChronicDisease
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/MichaelKummer.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/MichaelKummer.elm
index 48c1b19..40ab827 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/MichaelKummer.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/MichaelKummer.elm
@@ -16,9 +16,9 @@ cuckMichaelKummer =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/mkummer82/status/1465755847917715464?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = OutrightNo
-          , dodgeProposition = "polyunsaturated fats cause cell damage, inflammation and metabolic dysfunction."
+          , dodgeProposition = "Polyunsaturated fats cause cell damage, inflammation and metabolic dysfunction."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSeedOilsReasonInflammation
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/MichaelManderville.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/MichaelManderville.elm
index 1f2398f..eeb5a26 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/MichaelManderville.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/MichaelManderville.elm
@@ -16,9 +16,9 @@ cuckMichaelManderville =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/The_Nutrivore/status/1503036463306489856?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = RanAway
-          , dodgeProposition = "a logically coherent position will have logically coherent answer to a logically coherent hypothetical."
+          , dodgeProposition = "A logically coherent position will have logically coherent answer to a logically coherent hypothetical."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Belief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propAnalyticalTruth
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/MikeMutzel.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/MikeMutzel.elm
index 47309f6..0924334 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/MikeMutzel.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/MikeMutzel.elm
@@ -17,14 +17,14 @@ cuckMikeMutzel =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/The_Nutrivore/status/1414457776982552576?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = RanAway
           , dodgeProposition = "COVID is nothing more than a cold to those that are healthy."
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Agnostic
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propEmpiricalClaim
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/TheNutrivore/status/1584645853771616256?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "there is little to no association between saturated fat and cardiovascular disease."
+          , dodgeProposition = "There is little to no association between saturated fat and cardiovascular disease."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSaturatedFatReason
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/MikeSweeney.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/MikeSweeney.elm
index 6aa6040..87fe9eb 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/MikeSweeney.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/MikeSweeney.elm
@@ -16,21 +16,21 @@ cuckMikeSweeney =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/TheNutrivore/status/1746962254052962552"
           , dodgeDescription = OutrightNo
-          , dodgeProposition = "vegan diets are nowhere near appropriate for the average person in society."
+          , dodgeProposition = "Vegan diets are nowhere near appropriate for the average person in society."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Agnostic
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = VagueProp
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/thelowcarb_rd/status/1654182805964836865"
           , dodgeDescription = GhostedMe
-          , dodgeProposition = "statistical gymnastics don't inform on real world mechanisms and hard outcomes."
+          , dodgeProposition = "Statistical gymnastics don't inform on real world mechanisms and hard outcomes."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Agnostic
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = VagueProp
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/TheNutrivore/status/1776652108646821913?t=Pf4sfAC1Z0pAcxGfQFr7oQ"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
           , dodgeProposition = "Cheerios cause nausea, vomiting, seizures, irregular heartbeat, liver damage, and coma."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp "No empirical evidence was provided for the claim, but I find it incredibly implausible."
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/NickEggleton.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/NickEggleton.elm
index 6677933..db2ff7d 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/NickEggleton.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/NickEggleton.elm
@@ -16,9 +16,9 @@ cuckNickEggleton =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/The_Nutrivore/status/1266626885703720961?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = OutrightNo
-          , dodgeProposition = "polyunsaturated fats are poison."
+          , dodgeProposition = "Polyunsaturated fats are poison."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Agnostic
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = VagueProp
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/NinaTeicholz.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/NinaTeicholz.elm
index c83e719..e05a2bc 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/NinaTeicholz.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/NinaTeicholz.elm
@@ -16,21 +16,21 @@ cuckNinaTeicholz =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/TheNutrivore/status/1556510529014882305?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "the science linking red meat to heart disease is very weak."
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Agnostic
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeProposition = "The science linking red meat to heart disease is very weak."
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp "The aggregate of the data suggests red meat increases the risk of heart disease."
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/TheNutrivore/status/1467571763865210881?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "the available evidence supports limiting saturated fat intake for coronary heart disease risk reduction."
+          , dodgeProposition = "The available evidence supports limiting saturated fat intake for coronary heart disease risk reduction."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Belief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSaturatedFatReason
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/TheNutrivore/status/1538895943050878977?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "vegans pretend biology isn't real."
+          , dodgeProposition = "Vegans pretend biology isn't real."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Agnostic
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = VagueProp
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/NorstrongChris.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/NorstrongChris.elm
index e2cef77..0e04b6f 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/NorstrongChris.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/NorstrongChris.elm
@@ -16,21 +16,21 @@ cuckNorstrongChris =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/NorstrongHealth/status/1416939281973530626?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = RanAway
-          , dodgeProposition = "government funded USDA data is untrustworthy."
+          , dodgeProposition = "Government funded USDA data is untrustworthy."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Agnostic
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = VagueProp
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/The_Nutrivore/status/1534573919562350594?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = OutrightNo
-          , dodgeProposition = "nutrition science as a whole is shit."
+          , dodgeProposition = "Nutrition science as a whole is shit."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Agnostic
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = VagueProp
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/TheNutrivore/status/1534614710196260865?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "nutrition science as a whole is shit."
+          , dodgeProposition = "Nutrition science as a whole is shit."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Agnostic
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = VagueProp
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/PaulMason.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/PaulMason.elm
index e8bca03..ec8e23e 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/PaulMason.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/PaulMason.elm
@@ -24,13 +24,13 @@ cuckPaulMason =
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
           , dodgeProposition = "Ancel Keys' Seven Countries Study was flawed."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Agnostic
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = VagueProp
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/The_Nutrivore/status/1461361726943760391?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "dietary linoleic acid is not a significant, independent concern for the development of chronic diseases."
+          , dodgeProposition = commonProps.propLinoleicAcid
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Agnostic
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSeedOilsReason
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/PaulSaladino.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/PaulSaladino.elm
index 641f23b..6de1324 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/PaulSaladino.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/PaulSaladino.elm
@@ -9,6 +9,10 @@ cuckPaulSaladino =
         name : String
         name =
             "Paul Saladino"
+
+        prop : String
+        prop =
+            "To exclude animal foods from the human diet is a nutritional catastrophe."
     in
     { cuckImage = formatCuckName name
     , cuckName = name
@@ -16,39 +20,39 @@ cuckPaulSaladino =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/The_Nutrivore/status/1275912849999695872?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "subsidies for corn and soy are huge contributors to the chronic disease epidemic in the US."
+          , dodgeProposition = "Subsidies for corn and soy are huge contributors to the chronic disease epidemic in the US."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Agnostic
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propEmpiricalClaim
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/FoodFirst_Ty/status/1282847039596843009?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "seed oils are not a significant, independent risk factor for public health."
+          , dodgeProposition = commonProps.propSeedOils
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Belief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSeedOilsReason
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/FoodFirst_Ty/status/1283449495682904064?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "to exclude animal foods from the human diet is a nutritional catastrophe."
+          , dodgeProposition = prop
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Agnostic
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propEmpiricalClaim
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/The_Nutrivore/status/1282851963902636032?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "to exclude animal foods from the human diet is a nutritional catastrophe."
+          , dodgeProposition = prop
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Agnostic
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propEmpiricalClaim
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/The_Nutrivore/status/1469136550046814219?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "nutritional epidemiology generally provides good causal estimates."
+          , dodgeProposition = "Nutritional epidemiology generally provides good causal estimates."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Belief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propNutritionalEpidemiology
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/TheNutrivore/status/1633831762509045766?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "linoleic acid wreaks havoc in your body."
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Agnostic
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeProposition = "Linoleic acid wreaks havoc in your body."
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSeedOilsReason
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/PhilipOvadia.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/PhilipOvadia.elm
index d806ebc..4d745b2 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/PhilipOvadia.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/PhilipOvadia.elm
@@ -16,15 +16,15 @@ cuckPhilipOvadia =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/TheNutrivore/status/1557791520324890624?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "sugar is the problem and meat is the solution."
+          , dodgeProposition = "Sugar is the problem and meat is the solution."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Agnostic
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = VagueProp
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/TheNutrivore/status/1558282337024180224?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
           , dodgeProposition = "LDL doesn't cause coronary heart disease because it is just part of the arterial repair process."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propLDLCausality
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/PhilippeStephenson.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/PhilippeStephenson.elm
index cd9a858..90ab473 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/PhilippeStephenson.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/PhilippeStephenson.elm
@@ -16,9 +16,9 @@ cuckPhilippeStephenson =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/TheNutrivore/status/1779587012120715433"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "seed oils save lives."
+          , dodgeProposition = "Seed oils save lives."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Belief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSeedOilsReason
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/RalphNapolitano.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/RalphNapolitano.elm
index 73e6110..6d4104a 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/RalphNapolitano.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/RalphNapolitano.elm
@@ -16,9 +16,9 @@ cuckRalphNapolitano =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/The_Nutrivore/status/1462794580848300034?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "oatmeal is one of the worst foods you can eat and has no health benefits."
+          , dodgeProposition = "Oatmeal is one of the worst foods you can eat and has no health benefits."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp "The aggregate of the data suggests whole grains are beneficial for humans."
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/RaphaelSirtoli.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/RaphaelSirtoli.elm
index 411e24b..6b97666 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/RaphaelSirtoli.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/RaphaelSirtoli.elm
@@ -16,15 +16,15 @@ cuckRaphaelSirtoli =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/raphaels7/status/1475767357188579329?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = OutrightNo
-          , dodgeProposition = "the diet-heart hypothesis is false."
+          , dodgeProposition = "The diet-heart hypothesis is false."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSaturatedFatReason
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/raphaels7/status/1783541746015654072"
           , dodgeDescription = KillScreen
-          , dodgeProposition = "seed oils are not a significant, independent risk factor for public health."
+          , dodgeProposition = commonProps.propSeedOils
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Belief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSeedOilsReason
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/RobMeijer.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/RobMeijer.elm
index f12b2fb..a6d54c2 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/RobMeijer.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/RobMeijer.elm
@@ -18,7 +18,7 @@ cuckRobMeijer =
           , dodgeDescription = RanAway
           , dodgeProposition = noProposition
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Nothing
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = Vague
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/RobbWolf.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/RobbWolf.elm
index 25b7142..140b519 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/RobbWolf.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/RobbWolf.elm
@@ -16,9 +16,9 @@ cuckRobbWolf =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/TheNutrivore/status/1601624559647875072?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = OutrightNo
-          , dodgeProposition = "ancestral foods are more likely to be antagonistically pleiotropic than novel foods."
+          , dodgeProposition = "Ancestral foods are more likely to be antagonistically pleiotropic than novel foods."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Belief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propAnalyticalTruth
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/SimonGoddek.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/SimonGoddek.elm
index bb227fa..63af3f0 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/SimonGoddek.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/SimonGoddek.elm
@@ -9,6 +9,10 @@ cuckSimonGoddek =
         name : String
         name =
             "Simon Goddek"
+
+        prop : String
+        prop =
+            "Vegetable oils increase the risk of heart disease."
     in
     { cuckImage = formatCuckName name
     , cuckName = name
@@ -16,21 +20,21 @@ cuckSimonGoddek =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/TheNutrivore/status/1795673579931255233"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "vegetable oils increase the risk of heart disease."
+          , dodgeProposition = prop
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSeedOilsReasonCVD
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/TheNutrivore/status/1795885929678196951"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "vegetable oils increase the risk of heart disease."
+          , dodgeProposition = prop
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSeedOilsReasonCVD
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/TheNutrivore/status/1795674575315112396"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "vegetable oils increase the risk of heart disease."
+          , dodgeProposition = prop
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSeedOilsReasonCVD
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/TravisStatham.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/TravisStatham.elm
index d0df3cf..74642a4 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/TravisStatham.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/TravisStatham.elm
@@ -9,6 +9,10 @@ cuckTravisStatham =
         name : String
         name =
             "Travis Statham"
+
+        prop : String
+        prop =
+            "Seed oils do not cause obesity."
     in
     { cuckImage = formatCuckName name
     , cuckName = name
@@ -16,15 +20,15 @@ cuckTravisStatham =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/The_Nutrivore/status/1461428023207489542?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "seed oils do not cause obesity."
+          , dodgeProposition = prop
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Belief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSeedOilsReasonObesity
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://www.reddit.com/r/StopEatingSeedOils/comments/v457tu/how_vegetable_oils_make_us_fat_zero_acre/ic9u7wu/?utm_source=share"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "seed oils do not cause obesity."
+          , dodgeProposition = prop
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Belief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSeedOilsReasonObesity
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/TristanHaggard.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/TristanHaggard.elm
index 896373b..537ef68 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/TristanHaggard.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/TristanHaggard.elm
@@ -16,9 +16,9 @@ cuckTristanHaggard =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/The_Nutrivore/status/1513596227052527621?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = RanAway
-          , dodgeProposition = ""
+          , dodgeProposition = "Seed oils are toxic."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Agnostic
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = VagueProp
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/TroKalayjian.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/TroKalayjian.elm
index 9b37ed6..55424a1 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/TroKalayjian.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/TroKalayjian.elm
@@ -16,9 +16,9 @@ cuckTroKalayjian =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/The_Nutrivore/status/1261351818430255104?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = RanAway
-          , dodgeProposition = "Dr. Tho engages in shitty behaviour that causes people to dislike him."
+          , dodgeProposition = "Dr. Tro engages in shitty behaviour that causes people to dislike him."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Belief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp "The proposition seems trivially true."
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/TuckerGoodrich.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/TuckerGoodrich.elm
index b718535..a217d80 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/TuckerGoodrich.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/TuckerGoodrich.elm
@@ -16,9 +16,9 @@ cuckTuckerGoodrich =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/The_Nutrivore/status/1276694117494358017?s=19"
           , dodgeDescription = RanAway
-          , dodgeProposition = "nutritional epidemiology is almost always wrong."
+          , dodgeProposition = "Nutritional epidemiology is almost always wrong."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propNutritionalEpidemiology
           }
         , { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/TuckerGoodrich/status/1428062578668830720?s=20"
           , dodgeDescription = RanAway
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/ZoeHarcombe.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/ZoeHarcombe.elm
index 88461c5..057e4ef 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/ZoeHarcombe.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/CuckList/ZoeHarcombe.elm
@@ -16,9 +16,9 @@ cuckZoeHarcombe =
     , cuckDodges =
         [ { dodgeLink = "https://x.com/The_Nutrivore/status/1418263706178310149"
           , dodgeDescription = NoReply
-          , dodgeProposition = "saturated fat doesn't increase the risk of coronary heart disease."
+          , dodgeProposition = "Saturated fat doesn't increase the risk of coronary heart disease."
           , dodgeNicksDoxasticState = Just Disbelief
-          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = NoProp
+          , dodgeNicksDoxasticReason = SpecificProp commonPropReasons.propSaturatedFatReason
           }
         ]
     }
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/Helpers.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/Helpers.elm
index d152221..0ec165d 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/Helpers.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/Helpers.elm
@@ -63,24 +63,24 @@ makeDodge dodgeEntry index =
             , column [ width <| px 350, alignLeft ]
                 [ case dodgeEntry.dodgeNicksDoxasticState of
                     Nothing ->
-                        paragraph [ F.regular ] [ text "Nick doesn't form a doxastic state." ]
+                        paragraph [ F.regular ] [ text "I don't form a doxastic state." ]
 
                     Just Belief ->
                         paragraph [ F.regular ]
-                            [ text "Nick leans more toward "
+                            [ text "I lean more toward "
                             , el [ F.bold ] (text "TRUE")
                             , text " than false."
                             ]
 
                     Just Disbelief ->
                         paragraph [ F.regular ]
-                            [ text "Nick leans more toward "
+                            [ text "I lean more toward "
                             , text "FALSE" |> el [ F.bold ]
                             , text " than true."
                             ]
 
                     Just Agnostic ->
-                        el [ F.regular ] (text "Nick doesn't form beliefs about this proposition.")
+                        el [ F.regular ] (text "I don't form beliefs about this proposition.")
                 ]
             ]
         , row (paragraphBoldFormat ++ [ width fill ])
@@ -92,12 +92,12 @@ makeDodge dodgeEntry index =
                     [ text <|
                         case dodgeEntry.dodgeNicksDoxasticReason of
                             NoProp ->
-                                "there is no proposition to evaluate."
+                                "There is no proposition to evaluate."
 
-                            Vague ->
-                                "the proposition is too vague to evaluate."
+                            VagueProp ->
+                                "The proposition is too vague to evaluate."
 
-                            Specific str ->
+                            SpecificProp str ->
                                 str
                     ]
                 ]
diff --git a/frontend/src/Cuckery/Types.elm b/frontend/src/Cuckery/Types.elm
index 774c70c..f8b0f30 100755
--- a/frontend/src/Cuckery/Types.elm
+++ b/frontend/src/Cuckery/Types.elm
@@ -35,8 +35,8 @@ type DoxasticState
 
 type Evaluation
     = NoProp
-    | Vague
-    | Specific String
+    | VagueProp
+    | SpecificProp String
 
 
 type alias FormattedCuckName =
@@ -63,3 +63,47 @@ formatCuckSocial name =
 noProposition : String
 noProposition =
     "N/A"
+
+
+type alias CommonProps =
+    { propSeedOils : String
+    , propLinoleicAcid : String
+    }
+
+
+commonProps : CommonProps
+commonProps =
+    { propSeedOils = "Seed oils are not a significant, independent risk factor for public health."
+    , propLinoleicAcid = "Dietary linoleic acid is not a significant, independent concern for the development of chronic diseases."
+    }
+
+
+type alias PropReasons =
+    { propSaturatedFatReason : String
+    , propSeedOilsReason : String
+    , propSeedOilsReasonCVD : String
+    , propSeedOilsReasonCancer : String
+    , propSeedOilsReasonInflammation : String
+    , propSeedOilsReasonObesity : String
+    , propSeedOilsReasonChronicDisease : String
+    , propLDLCausality : String
+    , propEmpiricalClaim : String
+    , propAnalyticalTruth : String
+    , propNutritionalEpidemiology : String
+    }
+
+
+commonPropReasons : PropReasons
+commonPropReasons =
+    { propSaturatedFatReason = "The aggregate of the data overwhelmingly supports the hypothesis that heart disease risk can be influenced by changes in blood lipids as a function of saturated fat intake."
+    , propSeedOilsReason = "The aggregate of the data suggests seed oils are beneficial for humans."
+    , propSeedOilsReasonCVD = "The aggregate of the data suggests seed oils decrease the risk of heart disease."
+    , propSeedOilsReasonCancer = "The aggregate of the data suggests seed oils decrease the risk of cancer."
+    , propSeedOilsReasonInflammation = "There's no persuasive evidence that seed oils reliable influence inflammation in either direction."
+    , propSeedOilsReasonObesity = "There's no persuasive evidence that seed oils reliable influence obesity in either direction."
+    , propSeedOilsReasonChronicDisease = "The aggregate of the data suggests seed oils decrease the risk of chronic disease."
+    , propLDLCausality = "The highest tiers of evidence show an overwhelmingly consistent linear and proportional relationship between the concentration of low-density lipoproteins in the blood and coronary heart disease, regardless of population characteristics."
+    , propEmpiricalClaim = "This is an empirical claim that requires empirical evidence, and none was provided."
+    , propAnalyticalTruth = "The proposition is simply a trivial analytical truth."
+    , propNutritionalEpidemiology = "With exposures matched, nutritional epidemiology agrees with nutritional randomized controlled trials approximately 91% of the time."
+    }