feat: updating arguments

This commit is contained in:
Nick 2024-11-16 18:34:05 -06:00
parent f2647072fb
commit 600f2ed3f4
34 changed files with 384 additions and 397 deletions

View file

@ -5,50 +5,35 @@ import Debate.Types exposing (..)
argumentAntagonisticPleiotropy : Argument
argumentAntagonisticPleiotropy =
{ argumentTitle = "Title"
, propositionTitle = "Proposition"
{ argumentTitle = "Argument Against Ancestral Diets"
, propositionTitle = "Ancestral diets have inherent disadvantages over novel diets"
, propositionSummary = "Summary"
, proofLink = ""
, proofLink = "https://www.umsu.de/trees/#(P~5Q),(Q~5R),(P)|=(R)"
, definitionTable =
[ { definiendum = ""
, definiens = "prop 1"
[ { definiendum = "P"
, definiens = "humans have more genetic adaptations to ancestral foods than novel foods"
}
, { definiendum = ""
, definiens = "prop 2"
, { definiendum = "Q"
, definiens = "antagonistic pleiotropy is more of a concern for ancestral foods than novel foods"
}
, { definiendum = ""
, definiens = "prop 3"
}
, { definiendum = ""
, definiens = "prop 4"
}
, { definiendum = ""
, definiens = "prop 5"
}
, { definiendum = ""
, definiens = "variable 1"
, { definiendum = "R"
, definiens = "ancestral diets have inherent disadvantages over novel diets"
}
]
, argumentFormalization =
[ { premises =
[ { premise = "premise 1"
, notation = ""
[ { premise = "If humans have more genetic adaptations to ancestral foods than novel foods, then antagonistic pleiotropy is more of a concern for ancestral foods than novel foods."
, notation = "(PQ)"
}
, { premise = "premise 2"
, notation = ""
, { premise = "If antagonistic pleiotropy is more of a concern for ancestral foods than novel foods, then ancestral diets have inherent disadvantages over novel diets."
, notation = "(QR)"
}
, { premise = "premise 3"
, notation = ""
}
, { premise = "premise 4"
, notation = ""
}
, { premise = "premise 5"
, notation = ""
, { premise = "Humans have more genetic adaptations to ancestral foods than novel foods."
, notation = "(P)"
}
]
, conclusion = "conclusion"
, conclusionNotation = "()"
, conclusion = "Therefore, ancestral diets have inherent disadvantages over novel diets"
, conclusionNotation = "(R)"
}
]
}

View file

@ -11,43 +11,43 @@ argumentArtificialManipulation =
, proofLink = ""
, definitionTable =
[ { definiendum = ""
, definiens = "prop 1"
, definiens = ""
}
, { definiendum = ""
, definiens = "prop 2"
, definiens = ""
}
, { definiendum = ""
, definiens = "prop 3"
, definiens = ""
}
, { definiendum = ""
, definiens = "prop 4"
, definiens = ""
}
, { definiendum = ""
, definiens = "prop 5"
, definiens = ""
}
, { definiendum = ""
, definiens = "variable 1"
, definiens = ""
}
]
, argumentFormalization =
[ { premises =
[ { premise = "premise 1"
[ { premise = ""
, notation = ""
}
, { premise = "premise 2"
, { premise = ""
, notation = ""
}
, { premise = "premise 3"
, { premise = ""
, notation = ""
}
, { premise = "premise 4"
, { premise = ""
, notation = ""
}
, { premise = "premise 5"
, { premise = ""
, notation = ""
}
]
, conclusion = "conclusion"
, conclusion = ""
, conclusionNotation = "()"
}
]

View file

@ -11,43 +11,43 @@ argumentHealthSeeker =
, proofLink = ""
, definitionTable =
[ { definiendum = ""
, definiens = "prop 1"
, definiens = ""
}
, { definiendum = ""
, definiens = "prop 2"
, definiens = ""
}
, { definiendum = ""
, definiens = "prop 3"
, definiens = ""
}
, { definiendum = ""
, definiens = "prop 4"
, definiens = ""
}
, { definiendum = ""
, definiens = "prop 5"
, definiens = ""
}
, { definiendum = ""
, definiens = "variable 1"
, definiens = ""
}
]
, argumentFormalization =
[ { premises =
[ { premise = "premise 1"
[ { premise = ""
, notation = ""
}
, { premise = "premise 2"
, { premise = ""
, notation = ""
}
, { premise = "premise 3"
, { premise = ""
, notation = ""
}
, { premise = "premise 4"
, { premise = ""
, notation = ""
}
, { premise = "premise 5"
, { premise = ""
, notation = ""
}
]
, conclusion = "conclusion"
, conclusion = ""
, conclusionNotation = "()"
}
]

View file

@ -11,43 +11,43 @@ argumentImmortalityReductio =
, proofLink = ""
, definitionTable =
[ { definiendum = ""
, definiens = "prop 1"
, definiens = ""
}
, { definiendum = ""
, definiens = "prop 2"
, definiens = ""
}
, { definiendum = ""
, definiens = "prop 3"
, definiens = ""
}
, { definiendum = ""
, definiens = "prop 4"
, definiens = ""
}
, { definiendum = ""
, definiens = "prop 5"
, definiens = ""
}
, { definiendum = ""
, definiens = "variable 1"
, definiens = ""
}
]
, argumentFormalization =
[ { premises =
[ { premise = "premise 1"
[ { premise = ""
, notation = ""
}
, { premise = "premise 2"
, { premise = ""
, notation = ""
}
, { premise = "premise 3"
, { premise = ""
, notation = ""
}
, { premise = "premise 4"
, { premise = ""
, notation = ""
}
, { premise = "premise 5"
, { premise = ""
, notation = ""
}
]
, conclusion = "conclusion"
, conclusion = ""
, conclusionNotation = "()"
}
]

View file

@ -11,43 +11,43 @@ argumentPolyphenolReductio =
, proofLink = ""
, definitionTable =
[ { definiendum = ""
, definiens = "prop 1"
, definiens = ""
}
, { definiendum = ""
, definiens = "prop 2"
, definiens = ""
}
, { definiendum = ""
, definiens = "prop 3"
, definiens = ""
}
, { definiendum = ""
, definiens = "prop 4"
, definiens = ""
}
, { definiendum = ""
, definiens = "prop 5"
, definiens = ""
}
, { definiendum = ""
, definiens = "variable 1"
, definiens = ""
}
]
, argumentFormalization =
[ { premises =
[ { premise = "premise 1"
[ { premise = ""
, notation = ""
}
, { premise = "premise 2"
, { premise = ""
, notation = ""
}
, { premise = "premise 3"
, { premise = ""
, notation = ""
}
, { premise = "premise 4"
, { premise = ""
, notation = ""
}
, { premise = "premise 5"
, { premise = ""
, notation = ""
}
]
, conclusion = "conclusion"
, conclusion = ""
, conclusionNotation = "()"
}
]