### Healthy Food Argument | **Definiendum** | **Definiens** | |:-------------------------------------------:|:----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | | **P** | A given food (x) is healthy compared to another given food (w) when in a given context (y) | | **Q** | when within that context (y) the consumption of that given food (x) is likely to increase the lag-time to the onset of illness, disease, or infirmity (z) when replacing another given other food (w) | | **p** | Pepsi | | **d** | trapped on a desert island | | **s** | starvation | | **l** | leafy greens |
P1) A given food is healthy compared to another given food when in a given context if, and only if, when within that context the consumption of that given food is likely to increase the lag-time to the onset of illness, disease, or infirmity when replacing a given other food.
(∀x∀y∀z∀w(Pxyw↔Qxyzw))
P2)
When trapped on a desert island the consumption of Pepsi increases the lag-time to the onset of starvation when replacing leafy greens.
(Qpdsl)
C)
Therefore, Pepsi is healthy compared to leafy greens when trapped on a desert island.
(∴Ppdl)

[Proof Tree](https://www.umsu.de/trees/#(~6x~6y~6z~6w(Pxyw~4Qxyzw)),(Qpdsl)|=(Ppdl)) --- # Hashtags #debate #arguments