diff --git a/🛡️ Debate/🗡️ Opponents/Alpha Shadow.md b/🛡️ Debate/🗡️ Opponents/Alpha Shadow.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..99cf01c --- /dev/null +++ b/🛡️ Debate/🗡️ Opponents/Alpha Shadow.md @@ -0,0 +1,22 @@ +# Debate 1 + +## Proposition +>Nick's tweet was a net negative for veganism + +## Analysis +1. negative with respect to what? + 1. +2. what's the evidence? + 1. isn't proven? lol + +## Clarified Proposition +>It's Alpha's intuition Nick's tweet was a net negative for veganism + +## Receipts + +--- + +# Hashtags + +#debate +#debate_opponents \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/🛡️ Debate/🗡️ Opponents/Dantas vs Stan.md b/🛡️ Debate/🗡️ Opponents/Dantas vs Stan.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..f339a42 --- /dev/null +++ b/🛡️ Debate/🗡️ Opponents/Dantas vs Stan.md @@ -0,0 +1,60 @@ +# Mock Debate 1 + +## Proposition + +>"veganism is classist" + +## Analysis + +1. veganism is unhealthy + 1. vitamin a + 2. need more medical care + +## Semantics + +1. classist + 1. unjustifiably treating people differently + +--- + +# Mock Debate 2 + +## Proposition + +>"I think eating animals is fine and I don't see an issue with it" + +## Analysis + +1. "it is ok to impose my morals by intervening on an ax murderer" +2. "it is not ok to impose your morals by intervening on my carnism" + +--- + +# Mock Debate 3 + +## Proposition + +>"it is wrong to lie to your kid about santa claus" + +## Analysis + +1. lying is wrong + 1. deontic principle? + 1. all lying is bad + 1. response: jews under your floorboards in nazi germany. lie about them being there? + 1. no + 2. lying is not always bad, but lying about santa is not worth it + 1. response: deprives them of important childhood experiences + 1. what's the evidence for that? + +## Thoughts + +1. it's just my value + 1. agnostic about the empirics + +--- + +# Hashtags + +#debate +#debate_opponents \ No newline at end of file